Close Menu
Machinery Asia
  • Home
  • Industry News
  • Heavy Machinery
  • Backhoe Loader
  • Excavators
  • Skid Steer
  • Videos
  • News & Media
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Machinery Asia
Subscribe
  • Home
  • Industry News
  • Heavy Machinery
  • Backhoe Loader
  • Excavators
  • Skid Steer
  • Videos
  • News & Media
Machinery Asia
You are at:Home » Ferrovial can keep £1m paid by collapsed JV partner, judge says
Industry News

Ferrovial can keep £1m paid by collapsed JV partner, judge says

Machinery AsiaBy Machinery AsiaJuly 24, 2023No Comments3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Tumblr

A collapsed contractor’s attempt to recover money it was contributing to a troubled joint venture (JV) with Ferrovial Agroman UK has been thrown out by a judge.

The decision, which overturns a ruling last December, refers to work by Lagan Construction Group and Ferrovial to improve the M8, M73 and M74 motorways in Scotland.

The Lagan Ferrovial JV was appointed by the Scottish Roads Partnership (SRP) for the work in February 2014.

As part of the works agreement, both firms had provided letters of credit from their banks as collateral. Shortly after Lagan went into administration in 2018, his bank paid £3.7m into a JV security account, as promised in the company’s letter of credit.

In July 2021, two years after the project was completed, the SRP released the remaining account balance (just over £1m after default deductions) to the JV.

This meant that the money effectively went to Ferrovial – which at the time had sole control of the JV – but Lagan, now run by administrators, argued that under the project contract it should have received the funds.

In December 2022, a commercial judge supported this view, saying that because the wording of the contract was ambiguous, “commercial common sense” should be applied to make a decision.

The dispute was based on whether the use of the term “contractor” in the works agreement, which is more than 200 pages long, referred to the JV itself or an individual partner in the company.

But now a judge in the Inner Chamber of the Court of Session in Scotland has overturned the previous decision, saying there was “no ambiguity” in the wording of the contract.

In his decision, Lord Carloway referred to the principle that “contracts are made by what people say, not by what they think within themselves”.

He added that even if commercial common sense was a relevant consideration, “the court would have had trouble finding” that it favored Lagan’s interpretation.

The two judges commented on the drafting of the works agreement. The commercial judge stated that whichever interpretation is used, the key clauses are “not cheerfully worded” and “do not fit well”.

Lord Carloway said the document “has the air of being stitched together from similar contracts, rather than tailor-made”.

In 2017, Ferrovial lost £48m on the M8 upgrade project. The company said the scheme had proved difficult “historically” due to “issues with the design, complexities on a derelict site and shortages of labor and materials in the local construction market”.

Source link

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Previous ArticleMajor projects body declares HS2 ‘unaffordable’
Next Article City of London approves plans for 63-storey towers
Machinery Asia
  • Website

Related Posts

13-year, $2 million New York Bridge rehab completes eighth of 11 projects

October 16, 2026

Blattner is a contractor for the $750 million wind power project in South Dakota

October 16, 2026

Flintco-Mortenson JV begins concrete deck on Oklahoma City’s $900 million NBA stadium

October 16, 2026
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
Don't Miss

Thieves use backhoe in attempted ATM robbery in Trinidad and Tobago | news

Kingsport Times News | Local news, weather and sports

13-year, $2 million New York Bridge rehab completes eighth of 11 projects

Blattner is a contractor for the $750 million wind power project in South Dakota

Popular Posts

Thieves use backhoe in attempted ATM robbery in Trinidad and Tobago | news

October 17, 2026

Kingsport Times News | Local news, weather and sports

October 17, 2026

13-year, $2 million New York Bridge rehab completes eighth of 11 projects

October 16, 2026

Blattner is a contractor for the $750 million wind power project in South Dakota

October 16, 2026
Heavy Machinery

How to choose the right car trailer for your vehicle?

October 15, 2026

How to choose between single axle and tandem axle trailers

September 30, 2026

Custom trailers designed for the way you work

September 29, 2026

Daily Trailer Knowledge: Something About Trailer Tires

September 22, 2026

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.